New Tarte Tartelette Toasted Palette or UD Naked Heat?!

[cici437]

Hey lovelies!

Omg have you guys seen the new Tartelette Toasted palette?!  It's so gorgeous!  I've been waiting MONTHS for this to come out.  I've been trying to decide between Naked Heat or Tartelette Toasted.  I know Toasted won't be out at Sephora until the end of October, but just wanted to get your thoughts on which palette would be more versatile.  

I tend to go for a more natural look for day to day, but I've been wanting a warm toned palette to experiment with.  I'm quite tanned (from San Diego, hey!) with warm undertones.

Thanks for your help!  Can't wait to get my hands on one of these ❤️

[Anonymous]

@cici437 I own both and I feel that if you own literally any other warm palette, you can skip the Tartelette Toasted palette. It isn't unique at all. The Naked Heat has more unique shades. 😇 

[liftinglady]

I have both, and both are awesome. But I am team Toasted🔥

[haileyt06]

I'd personally say the toasted palette, but watch this video!  It lists the pros and cons of each palate and gives swatches

[Anonymous]

heat!!

[bakeamuffin]

Toasted! 🔥

[valeolguin]

I personally would go for the Toasted palette, but again it depends on what you're looking for and what your style is. Are you more of a matte or shimmer look girl? The mattes in the toasted palette are much more pigmented and creamier than the ones in the Heat palette. But I like the quality and intensity of  the shimmers in the Heat palette more.

I personally tend to go for more matte looks so I prefer the Toasted palette and when I do want the shimmers on this palette to be more intense I just use a wet brush. Also, the Toasted palette is cheaper. It doesn't come with a brush but I never use the brushes that come with palettes anyway so for me it's not worth it to pay more for something I won't use. The mirror in the Tarte one is also bigger which I really like. Hope this helps!! 

[mani93]

I say taste. There are too many similar looking colors in the heat palette

[sydtomato]

Tarte hands down, there is more variety in the shades and I honestly thing Urban Decay shadows suck.  Tarte has one of my favourite formulas for eyeshadow, especially blendability.  The Tarte also has more shades for everyday but can also make a good smokey eye whereas the Urban Decay Heat is overall darker.  I ordered my tarte palette and can't wait to get it.

[jesscheems]

Naked Heat. @cici437

[PaletteAddict99]

I can verify to you @cici437 that this recommendation from @jesscheems is coming from a huge Tarte palette fan and also a very talented eyeshadow applicator 🙂

[Ginaxaysongkham]

I am thinking of getting the toasted pallet! I like those colors better.

[bakeamuffin]

Naked heat colours blend out looking very similar

[mkuprox]

Go for Heat... the variety is much better and the pigmentation payoff is better

---

cici437 wrote:

Hey lovelies!

Omg have you guys seen the new Tartelette Toasted palette?!  It's so gorgeous!  I've been waiting MONTHS for this to come out.  I've been trying to decide between Naked Heat or Tartelette Toasted.  I know Toasted won't be out at Sephora until the end of October, but just wanted to get your thoughts on which palette would be more versatile.  

I tend to go for a more natural look for day to day, but I've been wanting a warm toned palette to experiment with.  I'm quite tanned (from San Diego, hey!) with warm undertones.

Thanks for your help!  Can't wait to get my hands on one of these ❤️

---

[Riri80]

Credit: Trendmood1

 Here is an awesome comparison!  Trendmood did a fabulous job on this one!

[aligal26]

Hi!  The swatches were done by u.glow.girl

[xshelbyann]

Trendmood do the swatch though, she took it from another user (I mean she credited them, but I couldn't think of a word besides took that fit lol)

[Riri80]

Oh I am so sorry, I did not realize it was someone else who did the swatches.  I would have given credit where it is due.

[cici437]

Omg thank you for this!  This is is a perfect comparison!

[sydtomato]

Covering each side of the palette I see way more similarity and overall red and deep shades in Naked Heat and more everyday, versatile shades in the Tarte one.  When you cover each side you see how different they are.

[mnichole]

I waited until Toasted came out before purchasing either, I went with Heat. I have Tarteist Pro & In Bloom & I love them. However, Heat won this battle for me.