Dupes for discontinued Too Faced pallets

[shyvicki]

I'm looking for dupes for colors from the Too Faced Romantic Eye and Naked Eye pallets. I'm particularly wanting Makeup Geek shadows, but I'll also take suggestions of other brands as well.

[Anonymous]

Hi, My mom loves the  Eye palette, but it's been discontinued for a while. My plan was to build her a palette using dupe shadows from  reputed brand.  I found a  post where someone added dupes for the palette. The problem is that the post is old and many of the dupe shadows have been discontinued.  I'm not as familiar with single shadow brands and want to know face cream for oily skin (https://nicciskincare.com/products/tea-tree-face-gel), so I'm at a loss of where to look. I really wanted to surprise her for Christmas, so any dupe suggestions would be great. Thanks in advance.

[SnugglePuggle94]

@Anonymous Why don't you try ColourPop? You can make your own palette and the prices are amazing for the quality you get!

[shyvicki]

Thank you so much, lylysa! This is a huge help.

[lylysa]

You're welcome!

I know swatch images can vary some due to lighting and whatnot, so I tried to at least post shades I felt could be a match or very similar based upon multiple comparison images I could find. At the very least the below dupes in the MUG line would be a good starting place to check out replacement shades!

[lylysa]

Hi, shyvicki!

Here are reference images I'm using for the TF Naked Eyes palette:

For In The Buff, try Mirage (swatch on far left):

For Birthday Cake, try Barcelona Beach:

For Pink Cheeks, try Starry Eyed (Shimma Shimma mentioned below could also work as a close dupe, but Starry Eyed has more of that pink tone to the pearly finish):

For Pillow talk, try Taupe Notch:

For Satin Sheets, try I'm Peachless:

For Lap Dance, try Moondust:

For Like A Virgin, try Bedrock:

For Unmentionables, this is color you may need to layer MUG shadows. Try Bada Bind for that rich brown base and Houdini lightly applied on top to give it that subtle duo-chrome effect with that slight blue shift:

For Stiletto, try Corrupt:

[lylysa]

Hi, shyvicki!

I'm going to post some reference pics of the TF Romantic Eye Palette for reference:

For Soulmates, try MUG's Shimma Shimma:

For Kiss the Bride, try Sorbet (this one is a bit more on the peachy pink side versus a creamy pink, but is the most similar in terms of giving that soft, milky look), swatch is the second from the left:

For Bouquet Toss, try Mirage (pictured above as the first swatch on the left).

For I Do, try Friend Zone:

For Cut The Cake, try Rebel (which has that beautiful gold shimmer laid into that dusky violet shade):

For Honeymoon, try Preppy (this comes the closest in terms of color being that khaki-based gold but this formula is matte), if you want that high metallic finish that Honeymoon has, you may even consider layering Bleach Blonde over Preppy (it has that more neutral tone so it won't add an overly heavy "yellow" cast to the gold):

For Un-Veil, you may consider Mocha or Americano depending on how intense and opaque you want the dark shade to be:

For First Dance, try Taboo:

For Ever After, try Steampunk (this duo-chrome is a bit more intense, but try to use a softer/looser brush to apply it if you don't want it as deep in color pay off, the swatch below shows it solo on the left and layered with a black base on the right):