Discontinued Dupe

[ChelseaGee9]

Hello beautifuls! 😅

There's a discontinued product I'm trying to find a dupe for, and failing thus far. Hoping to get some expert help! 

It's the Milk Makeup Melatonin Lip Mask. It has this almost Vaseline consistency and I can't find anything that works as well or lasts all night like that mask did. They're killing me with the discontinues! Their hemp lip balm was the best. 😭

I have tried Laneige lip masks, and while they're great, they don't keep my lips hydrated until I wake up in the morning.

While I'm asking for a discontinued dupe, I'll share one I just stumbled on. Milk Makeup also used to have this lip balm in a stick that had physical exfoliants (exfoliates?) in it. Fenty actually has one that smells great and works just as well. Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Pro Kiss’r Lip-Loving Scrubstick 

[Blskogen]

@ChelseaGee9  I have been looking for a dupe for the Milk Melatonin lip mask too, that is how I stubbled on your post.  You look the words right out of my mouth! Nothing last like the Milk one. I wake up in the morning and my lips are still hydrated but the Laneige ones, are nice at first, but I wake up and my lips are dry.  I have purchased the Tacha lip balm, random ones on amazon, anything I can think of and nothing is as good as the Milk Melatonin one.  What magic did they put in it??  Have you found a dupe yet?  

[AnimalBrain]

Hi @ChelseaGee9 - not sure if it's a dupe, but have you tried any products with lanolin in them? I have been using "nipple cream" Lansinoh on my lips and it has a heavier consistency that Vaseline, so I find that it stays longer and really hydrates my lips. I hope this helps.

[gonerogue]

@ChelseaGee9  laneige is my go-to for a sleeping mask so I’m afraid I can’t be much help with that one but for the lip exfoliator, I love the Fresh one and a cheap alternative is also the E.L.F one from the drug store.

[ChelseaGee9]

Yay!! Thank you!! I love this Fenty one but I want to try those two you mentioned as well. 😊 It's only been like a week and it's almost gone.

[cstar1212]

@ChelseaGee9  let me know if you find a good replacement to the milk melatonin overnight lip mask as Im also looking and so sad its disontinued 😞 

[gonerogue]

@ChelseaGee9  Unfortunately, the same thing happens to me when I exfoliate my lips. That’s why I opt for the drugstore version since it’s only like three dollars and I can re-purchase as much as I want without it hurting my wallet lol