Please help me find a dupe to this lip liner! Essence Lovely Frappuccino!

[vyps]

Please help me find a dupe to the essence lip liner lovely frappuccino, it had a creamy long lasting formula. Greatly appreciate the help!! 

 

[Inccc]

@vyps maybe check out the NYX lip liner in shade “Mauve” or “Natural”? I will say these aren’t very creamy they’re more on the dry lip pencil side but you could do a very thin coat of the nyx butter gloss (in shade tiramisu or just clear) on top since it’s not a thick gloss and make it “creamy”. Or Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat Lip Liner - Pillow Talk Collection in either the original pillow talk shade or pillow talk medium? 

[vyps]

Amazing! Thanks!! I'll check them out ❤️