Mascara dupe?

[logan1992]

My favorite mascara of all time was Marc Jacobs At Lashed Lengthening and Curling mascara. Now that it is discontinued I am running out of my final tube, anyone have any recommendations to something similar? 

[ellie50]

All Marc Jacobs mascara's worked for me, too! I have been trying bunches of different mascara's trying to find a replacement.   I have straight, fine lashes so it could be just my lashes.

So far, IT Superhero is working best for me.  I also bought Pat McGrath Fetish Eyes and love it, but I think it may be slipping into my eyes and giving my RGB contact lenses with a waxy film.  Trying Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Push Up today, pillow talk is right, wearing for 3 hrs now and looks like I slept in in - racoon eyes (didn't apply on bottom lashes and curled my lashes).