How to replace Clinique Black Honey Brush On Cream Liner?!?!?

[MaryEileen]

Guys - I've tried every eyeliner there is on my waterline, and finally found 'the one', and it was promptly discontinued. I'm talking about Clinique Brush On Cream Liner in Black Honey. It was the only eyeliner that I've found that actually stayed on my waterline for more than two seconds. The True Black shade is just too much for my complexions. Please help! How can I ever replace Black Honey Bush On Cream Liner? 

[MaryEileen]

Thanks everyone! I've tried all your suggestions and Inglot has turned out to be the best replacement. It is soft but stays put for hours. Not all day, but long enough. Thanks again!!!

[lovehk620]

I know Sephora doesn't sell it but Inglot cream gel liners are great for the waterline and super affordable. Another good one is Marc Jacobs highliners and fineliners super smudge proof once set, perfect for the water line

[SamanthaCo]

I've never used cream on my waterline and stick to pencil. I love Estée Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil for my waterline. They have various colors but my go to is Onyx (black). It doesn't smudge and stays on forever.