Help!! My favourite eye liner is discontinued!!

[TiffAlexis]

I have been using Clinique’s skinny stick eyeliner since I was in grade 8....that was 10 years ago. I’ve just found out that it is now discontinued. Does anyone have any suggestions for eyeliners that are similar to the skinny stick or suggestions for a better kind. The more comments the better. It will give me more of an idea to browse through. Thanks!!!

[Amichsmith]

Stilla eyeliner is the bomb! Lasts a long time too.

[Anonymous]

24/7 glide on from Urban Decay in perversion. Only black you’ll ever need. Works well with contacts, light colored eyes, lash to lash line blending, and high pigment. Can stain your under eyes if the water line isn’t applied correctly.

[playingdressup]

Marc Jacobs also makes a skinny pencil liner with a great formula. I find its good on lid or waterline. I remember those Clinique pencils! Sorry your fave formula was discontinued. That's always frustrating.

https://www.sephora.com/product/fineliner-ultra-skinny-gel-eye-crayon-eyeliner-P404247?skuId=1773118...

[greeneyedgirl107]

@TiffAlexis If you are looking for a skinny liner, I also rec HG 1.5 mm.  Best of luck!  I've had multiple eyeliners discontinued on me and it's never fun 😞

[TiffAlexis]

Wow thanks! I’m going to go look into that ! I’m really upset about this haha

[PenelopeBT]

Hi @TiffAlexis,

I'm so sorry to hear your favorite eyeliner is discontinued. However, there are lots of great options right now. If you prefer a pencil eyeliner, I highly recommend Marc Jacobs Highliner. It's our best selling eyeliner and it doesn't smudge or smear (we're all looking for that, right?). It also comes in classic and fun shades. I hope this helps!

Stay Gorgeous,

Penelope

[TiffAlexis]

Hmmm ok. I’ll keep that in mind! Thank you so much!!!