Has anyone tried Urban Decay's new Troublemaker mascara?

[causticx]

I know it's not available in Sephora yet since it just launched on UD's website 2 days ago, but has anyone tried it yet? They were giving out samples to a select few via Instagram and I'm super curious about the brush/formula. 

Of course, Perversion went on sale today so I had to pick up a new tube. Guess I'll have to use that up and wait for Troublemaker to arrive in stores! (I asked a Sephora sales associate today and she didn't know when that would be, unfortunately.) 

[Indy701]

@causticx I got one of the samples and so far it's decent. It did leave a bit of a smudge under my eye after about 15 hours but that's longer than it takes most mascaras. This isn't a great picture but you can see it compared to Tarte's lights camera lashes. Left side of pic is UD  Those lashes do look longer and thicker.  it goes on nicely; no lumps 

[causticx]

Your lashes look great in the UD! Some other replies seemed disappointed by it. I'm hoping to end up with a sample so I can try before buying...

[Indy701]

Thanks. I work from home so I can sit around all day mismatched like this. lol. If I ever run out of mascara samples this is one I may buy. 

[jmw1]

Yes, I received a couple sample sizes of their new mascara and I don't think it's that great. It has plastic-like bristles that are spaced far apart. And although I prefer that type of brush style, these bristles were a little too far separated so that each hair wasn't covered unless you went over it a couple times or wiggled back and forth. while it adds volume, it didn't seem to add much length or curl to my eyelashes. I wore it today and ended up putting a second coat of another mascara after I got to work. It seems like an ok mascara, just not on my favorites list.

[causticx]

That figures. I guess I'd still like to try it if offered a sample. Thank you for the honesty! 

[ChristineR07]

While I haven't personally tried it (like you said it's not in store yet) the beauty guru's I've seen review it have not been impressed with it at all.  Because of that and having a holy grail mascara already (Burberry Cat Lash) I don't feel the need to try it out.  If there's a sample I'll probably give it a shot but it honestly doesn't sound worth it.

[causticx]

Well that's interesting (and a little disappointing to hear) -- hopefully, it'll be available as a point perk or in an upcoming Play box. I'd rather try it that way than spend $24 on it.