Benefit They're Real Brown: discontinued? Recommendations?

[RainyRose]

Perusing my Loves list this morning, it looks like Benefit's "They're Real" mascara in Beyond Brown is no longer available in the USA. This is the THIRD "go-to" Benefit product that has been discontinued in the last year (World's Greatest eyeshadow palettes, Erase Paste, now this) and I'm feeling pretty unhappy about it. I love Benefit products but I don't want to get burned again. Can anyone recommend to me a non-clumping, volumizing mascara in the brown/chocolate color family that you love? I'm blonde/blue eyes/super light skin. I can't wear black eyeliner or mascara.

Thanks,

Rose

[Shelley6]

I’m a redhead, pale, blue eyes with the same problem. Finding a good brown mascara is a real pain, isn’t it? I personally hated They’re Real but like Roller Lash in brown, even though it smudges on me. Lots of pale girls seem to like Lancôme Defincils in brown, though that one is very dark.

---

RainyRose wrote:

Perusing my Loves list this morning, it looks like Benefit's "They're Real" mascara in Beyond Brown is no longer available in the USA. This is the THIRD "go-to" Benefit product that has been discontinued in the last year (World's Greatest eyeshadow palettes, Erase Paste, now this) and I'm feeling pretty unhappy about it. I love Benefit products but I don't want to get burned again. Can anyone recommend to me a non-clumping, volumizing mascara in the brown/chocolate color family that you love? I'm blonde/blue eyes/super light skin. I can't wear black eyeliner or mascara.

Thanks,

Rose

---

[CarlyJA]

Unfortunately, it looks like roller lash in brown was pulled by benefit from Sephora and Ulta. The "they're real!" mascara in brown appears to be available on Ulta though!