Which one is better mascara:benefit or stilla

[Anonymous]

So I am currently running low on mascara and deciding between Benefit roller lash or Stila huge extreme lash mascara. Or any other drugstore recommendation is fine. I have short and straight eyelash (asian lash, lol) and been using Etude House Curl Fix mascara (I loved it). I tried Maybeline lash sensational waterproof version once, and that smudged way too much as well as it was hard to remove. 

[slfang]

I have Asian eyelashes that are sparse and short. I got the Benefit Roller Lash in hopes of curling my nonexistent eyelashes. It didn't do so at all and ended up going straight down again. I do think it works on longer eyelashes. 😕 I wouldn't get it but it didn't separate my eyelashes nicely and was easy to use for my bottom lashes.

[capri22]

Try Benefit..They're REAL........... If this does not give you some BAM.......then go with fake lashes. I work with Asain girls in the Casino......and They have your problem and just go fake.......GO easy on the style of fake tho.

[Giddy412]

I love the Benefit Rollerlash. My fave combo is to use the Rollerlash and then layer Too Faced Better Than Sex on top🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽

[MsLata]

Depends on what you want. Roller lash will lengthen and curl whereas stila's will lengthen, darken/sort of volumize, and give that "butterfly effect" to the lashes. These are the results I saw on me.

[Anonymous]

Oh im just curious which one would hold curl better and less smudge.

[kayjwlrs8]

I do agree. it all depends on the specific look you want ... and the brush itself and the texture of the brush. the roller lash tends to have a rubber coating