Hourglass Mechanical Gel Liner dupe

[darkchocolate68]

I bought the Hourglass gel liner for my tightline. I really like it, but it goes so fast. I have only had it 3 weeks and it is gone already. I didn't waste any, meaning it never broke off or I twisted it too much. I need to find an equivalent liner that is cheaper. I have used the NYX (I think it was Jolie liner) and it worked fine but the liner is too thick and I wasted more trying to sharpen it. Any suggestions?

[darlyndar]

I realllly enjoy the Sephora brand waterproof liner. It’s super dark, glides easily and doesn’t transfer. It’s the only thing that is comparable to my Marc Jacobs!

[greeneyedgirl107]

@darlyndar Is there a specific one that you like?  I'm interested in a pencil or gel-type pencil.  I own the Sephora Contour 12 Hr Wear Waterproof and also used the Sephora Matte Gel until it was discontinued; I've tried the Sephora Nano and maybe the Sephora Eye Pencil To Go. 

But there are also:

Sephora Contour Inner Rim Gel Eyeliner

Sephora Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner.

THANKS!  🙂

[darlyndar]

@greeneyedgirl107 i use the retractable waterproof liner. It’s amazing. You should definitely try it! 

[greeneyedgirl107]

@darlyndar Thanks for the tip!  I was hoping that you were referencing that one, b/c I have eyed it up in the past.  Now I have to have it!  🙂

[greeneyedgirl107]

@darkchocolate68 I posted the same question some time ago and never got an answer...I haven't found anything similar.  If you hear of anything, please tag me 🙂

[darkchocolate68]

@greeneyedgirl107 

I am going to try the Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Skinny Gel Eye Pencil.  I asked on another site and this was suggested often.  If I don't like it, I will return it.

[greeneyedgirl107]

@darkchocolate68 THANKS! I will try that one as well once I get the chance!

[Michie44]

This is the only liner I use for my waterline. It’s amazing and lasts all day, especially the black shade.

[naturalooks15]

@Michie44 Do you use Maybelline or the Hourglass one?