Comparable eyeliner to UD “West”?

[makeupmaven13624]

“West” came in a travel trip set and I’d love help finding a comparable eyeliner. UD called it “dark brown pearl” For eyeliner I like UD, but I’m open to Nars, Makeup Forever, or any other long lasting brand that applies smoothly.

[lmi82]

Hi, @makeupmaven13624.

I looked through Temptalia's Swatch Gallery and at a couple of other blogs, and have found some possible dupes. Some of the shades don't have shimmer, though, but they do look close in color. I've been referring to online swatches of UD West and some look like a dark chocolate brown whereas others are lighter and more bronzy. That's why there's some color variation in the dupe suggestions. Hopefully, at least one of them will look right to you. 

Urban Decay Bourbon ($20):

Image: Temptalia.

MAC Broque ($18):

Image: Temptalia. 

Sephora Collection 14 Cocoa ($10):

Image: Temptalia.

MUFE D-62 Diamond Brown ($21):

Image: Temptalia.

MUFE M-60 Matte Dark Brown ($21):

Image: Temptalia

Sephora Collection 13 Tiramisu ($10):

Image: Temptalia.

ColourPop Stomper Pencil ($5):

Image: Temptalia.

Chanel 932 Mat Taupe ($33):

Image: Temptalia.

MAC Teddy ($18):

Image: Delicate Hummingbird. 

Marc Jacobs Ro(Cocoa), Brown(ie), Brown(Out), or Earth(quake) ($25):

Image: The Beauty Look Book.

I hope this helps!