@kristenk15
Whew! That's a long list of products! Hopefully you won't have to go through all of it until you find a routine that works for you!
Here are the things I've tried (some, I love) from your list:
Fresh Soy Cleanser - I used a deluxe sample tube of it (it was quite large) and was nothing to write home about. Not particularly nourishing for my skin, and I'm leery of soy due to what it can do to hormones when ingested...not sure if using on skin has similar effect (I doubt it, but worth noting as too much soy tends to break me out). I still have a tube of this, thinking of using this to clean brushes (my plan for any cleansers I don't plan on using on my skin ever again)
Pixi Glow Tonic - I thought this product was OK, I can't say it did much for my skin since I used up the smaller size of it and have since switched back to my MISSHA essence and I'm not seeing any difference. I had high hopes for it though, as it is has a cult following it seems, sadly it just didn't do anything for me.
Sunday Riley Good Genes - I have used this and other AHA products and can't say it does any better than a less expensive option. I currently use Pixi Glow Serum (10% glycolic) and get similar results. It's about 30% of the price of a bottle of Good Genes, though!
Herbivore Phoenix Cell Regenerating Facial Oil - I have a rollerball of this and really like this oil. I like to use this on days I don't use retinol due to another acid being in my routine as it's so nourishing. If you have acne-prone combo skin, may I suggest you try Herbivore Lapis oil instead? It's meant to balance oil production. I have used up almost an entire bottle of it (it's my primary AM oil) and am seriously considering repurchasing. A bottle has lasted me over 2 years now, crazy! I even have a rollerball of it for traveling.
Herbivore Blue Tansy mask - I LOVE THIS STUFF. Finished an entire jar and about to open a new one. I have never had an adverse reaction to this mask and my skin always glows after. Helped shrink cysts on my face, although did not make them go away completely (before this though, nothing worked to make a difference). I follow the use 4 days in a row then cut back to once every 2-3 days and it helped improve my skin. I now use this mask approx. 1x/week for maintenance. Some people can't stand the smell but I don't find it offensive at all.
DDG Alpha Beta Peel Extra Strength - tried these, would not repurchase. I think they were too much for my skin. Some parts of my skin started to feel tight and flaky, especially the areas of my face that is normal. Warning- alcohol is listed as one of the top ingredients. I would recommend avoiding alcohol on breakout-prone skin as this could further irritate your skin. I do use the DDG Glow pads which has NO alcohol and has self tanner in addition to AHA and BHA, and I'm loving these.... would consider keeping as a permanent item in my routine even when summer is over, even if I don't need the self-tanner.
Biossance 100% Squalane Oil - I use the version with Vitamin C and rose. I LOVE it. I use it at night and mix one drop with my AM face oil...it absorbs so quickly and not greasy. My skin looks great using this product. I'd imagine the plain 100% squalane would be about the same, but I think you can get a cheaper version at Deciem especially if you just want 100% squalane.