replacement brand for Origins eye pencil

[jjdynomite]

I believe Origins discontinued their Automagically™ Eye Lining Pencil.   Can anyone recommend a similar brand?  I loved their slate and chocolate colors and they lasted all day.

[PenelopeBT]

Hi @jjdynomite.,

If you're looking for a similar product, I recommend the CLINIQUE - Quickliner for Eyes - Dark Chocolate . It's a creamy, transfer resistant formula that is easy to apply and has a built in smudger. I love the shade dark chocolate if you're looking for an everyday brown shade. 

[hilparr]

I haven’t found anything similar. Have you?! I’m devastated. It was the best eyeliner ever and lasted all day and the most perfect shade of indigo ever. Why do companies do that?! 😵

[jjdynomite]

Cover girl is the closest thing