Tubing mascara plus add waterproof?

[CattyTammy]

I finally discovered why even the strongest waterprood mascara ends up smudging underneath my eyes: oily lashes! I was driving myself crazy running from mascara to mascara. Then, I learned about tubing mascara. Is this something I can use in harmony with waterproof? I read that tubing is not very curling. Mine are pretty curled on their own. But if I put on a tubing masc and then add waterproof over it ... will that be helpful? Or does that make no sense?

Love Too Faced Better Than Sex and Benefit Fan Fare. Broke my heart when I had dark pools of mascara underneath my eyes.

Tubing: e.l.f.Lash EXTNDR (user reviews kind of rough .. hard to use for some reason), Tarte tartlette, L'oreal Double Extend Beauty. Any rex? Cannot wait to get my mascara to STAY.

Thanks.

[CorgiMommy]

@CattyTammy unfortunately because of the ingredients that go into a tubing mascara they can only be water resistant