Sephora Colorful Shadow and Liner Pencil- GREY STONE

[taxbird]

Hello!!!  With the rebranding, it appears my holy grail Sephora Colorful Shadow and Pencil in GREY STONE sadly did not come back 😔😔😔

It was the most perfect midtone grey matte pencil that lasted all day on me and that I used almost daily!!  I searched and asked Sephora and MAC counter and no luck

Any recommendations as a replacement?? 

Thanks!

[danielledanielle]

You might be able to find 1-2 on a third party site @taxbird , from what I can search and try to compare...there's SEPHORA COLLECTION 12 Hour Contour Pencil Eyeliner 51 Stone , but the formula is different.  HAUS LABS BY LADY GAGA Optic Intensity Eco Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil Charcoal Matte might work, but currently out of stock

[taxbird]

Appreciate the time you took for suggestions, but sadly.those are far darker than the mid to lighter tone of the old pencil.  Thanks for the rec though!

[danielledanielle]

@taxbird, no problem... I'll bookmark this thread in case I come across something

ETA: in a different post due a different shade @Samtian suggested colorfix! Danessa Myricks Beauty Colorfix - Multi-Use Eye, Cheek & Lip Waterproof Liquid Pigment Trooper ...there's also another grey.  If those don't work, she has more .... The line has I think 70+ finishes and colors available, with mattes included.  Our @sister13 might be able to help with a swatch of you're interested