Which Benefit brow colour?

[Nessalm]

I am trying to figure out which Benefit brow pencil colour would be best for me (Goof Proof or Precisely). I have been wearing a shade 3 but I think it is a bit too dark/brown. I am looking to try the shade 2 or 2.5. I have natural dark blond hair that is usually highlighted a light blond. Fair skin colour, blue eyes. With the stores closed, I can’t go in and ask! Any help??? I have attached a picture of my natural eyebrows - quality isn’t very good, sorry. Thank you

[dar27]

I would say try the shade 2.5. The 2 might not be defining enough.

[jenner18]

You could consider getting the Benefit Cosmetics Brow Contour Pro Brown Medium in blonde/light because it has two different colors that you could use. I see they are on sale and this color looks out of stock, but maybe you can find it somewhere else. 

As for the color recommendation of the pencil, I think the neutral blonde might be best (2.5) unless your hair and brow color is warmer/golden. Natural is always in the middle of cool and warm. To me you brows do not look too warm, but it’s hard to tell without seeing your hair color as well. 

Not sure if this helps, but food for thought. Maybe try to get the mini size before the full size as well.