Birchbox vs. Sephora Play?

[Lizzie541]

Has anyone tried both? I currently have birchbox but I'm wondering if Sephora Play is better? Let me know what you think!

[leannaz]

I feel like i get 1 item i like maybe 2 in all the boxes i have Ipsy birch and Sephora .. Sephora does have more high end stuff but from month to month it’s either a hit or miss i don’t love all items in any box i get

[cfwills13]

Sephora is much better! Birchbox only gives you samples, like one- time use samples. Where Sephora gives you deluxe samples to try several times.

[DebKaye]

I did Birchbox before this for about a year. I def think Sephora is better. I started getting the same products over and over after a while. I never got perfume. I always got lipstick, which I hate. I quit Birchbox a while back. Sephora actually pays attention to your profile. The brands are amazing. You get perfume every month, in addition to the other 5 samples. I love the Sephora box! I also did Ipsy. I quit that one too.

[Anonymous]

I did the birch box for 1 month and did this one at the same timw. I was disappointed with the birch box and cancelled it.