Eyebrow pencil for redheads

[Mainabanana]

I’m looking for a really basic, on the go eyebrow pencil that’s good for natural redheads! Every single one that I’ve tried are either too dark or straight up orange... would someone have a recommendation that’s also cruelty free? I don’t know anymore! Thank you xxx

[epmauck]

I'm a natural strawberry blond and I use ABH's brow definer in caramel. It can look too dark sometimes if I go too heavy, but when I use a lighter hand, it's great.

[GG84]

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz® Ultra-Slim Precision Eyebrow Pencil Taupe  in Auburn 

[fieldsofclover]

This is the very first thing I hunted down and bought at Sephora in... 2001? All downhill from there 🙈

[Anonymous]

I feel your frustration. I haven’t found a pencil yet but I’ve got other options that really work. There are some shadows that work really well, like Tarte’s Leader.

[Missebee]

I just discovered that Sephora Brand has this retractable eyebrow pencil in Honey Blonde which is lighter than ABH Carmel and similar to the discontinued Strawberry Blonde pencil from MAC. It's great for lighter redheads!!!!! Not too dark!