Which Tarte concealer is better?

[Anonymous]

I quite literally just bought the Shape Tape concealer from Tarte and then I saw the Maracuja Creaseless Concealer from Tarte on my Sephora app, and I'm wondering if anyone has any experience with both to say which is better? Thanks! 😄

[Saraa26]

After becoming a Tarte shape tape addict, and finding my perfect match with the medium shade, just looking to see which of Tarte's foundations would work best for me. I've been using Make Up Forever May Velvet for as long as I can remember, a 40 or 45 depending on the season, but noticed this isn't really the best match with the medium shape tape.

I used the foundation finder on Tarte's website which recommend either the Amazonian clay 12-hour full coverage foundation or the Rainforest of the Sea water foundation. Just curious to hear about experiences with either, and how they might compare to the Mat Velvet 🙂 

[Sheabutter00]

I am OBSESSED with my rainforest of the sea foundation, its light but covering and keeps a natural look and feel to it.

[Anonymous · Accepted solution]

I have personal tried both... My opinion is that they have about the same CRAZY coverage but the maracuja is a bit more thick so I would go with the Tarte Shape Tape.

[Anonymous]

Thank you, I definitely don't want a thicker formula, as it usually settles into the fine lines around my eyes and just makes them look deeper, which makes me look older. I have been on the hunt for the perfect foundation and concealer combo for the longest time.

[pg29s]

I haven't used the Maracuja concealer, but now I am curious. It took me 6 months to get my hands on the Shape Tape as my shade was always sold out. I have not been disappointed as it is like a miracle concealer. Not a complaint at all. It could also possible be the same product, just marketed differently since Shape Tape is an Ulta exclusive.