Dupe for NARS New Lover?

[DoriMaxwell]

So I adore Nars velvet Gloss pencil in New Lover. It’s the perfect shimmery, sheer peachy pink with gold glimmer. But I hate having to sharpen the pencil (AND it’s on backorder). None of the dupes on Temptalia are quite right or they are no longer being made. Anybody have any suggestions for something similar? I would prefer a lipstick or gloss rather than a pencil, but I’m desperate, so if you think it’s close I’ll try it.

[lmi82]

Hi, @DoriMaxwell. That's a beautiful lip color! It's a shame that it turns out to be such a rare shade. It seems like every good dupe I stumbled upon was either a very old limited edition product or had been discontinued. Anyway, here are some possibilities...

Kevyn Aucoin Poppy Topaz ($30):

Bottom left.

First on the right.

Sephora Collection 11 Fancy Peach ($14):

Image: Temptalia.   

ABH Parfait ($16):

Image: Temptalia.
Image: SUPERNOVABEAUTY.

Ciate Luna ($18):

Image: Temptalia.

Tarte Pink Sand ($21; limited edition):

If you end up not finding a perfect dupe, you could always Frankenstein a lip color by topping a coral base with some pigmented gold metallic or shimmer gloss.

I hope this helps!