Charlotte Tilbury Magic Away Dupe

[Nemhain]

Does anyone know a great concealer dupe for Charlotte Tilbury Magic Away in shade 2? The shade is just the right tone for me (a lot of things are too yellow or too white) but the applicator is really bad. It has one of those sponge tips that make all of the concealer congeal and crust around it, and the concealer itself applies a bit powdery/cakey. The shade is perfection, though.

[SportyGirly125]

@Nemhain Tarte Shape Tape

[Nemhain]

What shade would you guess? I've used that before in Fair Neutral and it was really pale.

[SportyGirly125]

@Nemhain

do you have an Ulta store where you can see the shades? Or maybe contact or call Tarte to see which shade would work for you 

[Nemhain]

I've been avoiding going to more things in-person than needed with the pandemic but asking online or calling is a good idea. I figured I'd check with the community first in case anyone had done a swatch comparison video or blog, or just had experience with that particular concealer. I've seen tons of comparisons or reviews out there for various brands but hadn't caught any using Magic Away in my shade range.