You could try setting your eyes with a translucent powder like the Cheekbone Beauty Mattifying Moon Dust Setting Powder 0.38 oz / 9 g and then using a liner brush and a dark eyeshadow to add liner @pineapplepiggy . You could also try this with a liquid liner after, but depending on the formula might get all gunky. I also think water activated liners or cake liners tend to last a bit better. I've heard great things about the Glisten and Diverune ones.I don't use a ton of felt/liquid liners but the Kaja Wink Stamp Original Waterproof Wing Eyeliner Stamp & Pen and the stila Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner have both held up for my oily lids really well in the past.Hope you find something that works!!

Hi, @HusbandsWifey ! I usually use a transition shade, but not always. It depends on how many colors I'm using and what look I'm going for. I like using a light neutral color.

@gretadosch have you tried curling after applying mascara?

    natasha denona roxa palette

@sephorabuyer25 @Sephora employee here the next shade up would be NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer with Hydrating Medium Coverage Café Au Lait it has the same neutral undertone but with a little peach

@Ispend2much6 thank you. That helps.