Dark Circles - It Cosmetics Bye bye under eye cream vs Clinique All about eyes rich?

[lorasu08]

I’m shopping for an under eye cream for my dark circles. Has anyone used both of these? If so, which do you prefer?

[EmmaJoey]

The Bye Bye Undereye is so opaque and thick I was started. A little tiny dab will conceal your entire undereye and no color is getting through. It lasts all day easily and doesn't crease. It's such an interesting texture, like a thick gel. You'll want a setting powder though. I use NYX with it. It's so good it even covers up popped pimples that no other makeup will stick to, like magic. If you have pronounced dark circles, Bye Bye all the way. If you have pretty even skin that needs a little help, Clinique.

[RachFace2921]

Hi @lorasu08.  I have not used clinique, but really like It Bye Bye Undereye, and have had some luck with it lessening dark circles.  It is one of only 2 eye products I've found that don't make my eyes water.  If you have sensitive eyes, that can be a make or break.  Also wears great under makeup.

If you're near a store, you can request samples of each.  They can make a little container for you.

[TexasMeow]

I second this, I haven’t used the Clinique but I got Bye Bye Under-eye in my Ipsy bag and it has serious coverage without feeling caked on! I apply with a mini beauty blender and a little goes a long way.

[RachFace2921]

Hi @TexasMeow, did you get the eye cream or the concealer?  I've actually tried both, though the concealer was a bit thick / heavy for what I need.  If you've not used the eye cream, which is a cloudy blue color, I do recommend!

[TexasMeow]

Oh ha! I guess it’d be the concealer! Confusing that they have the same name! I’ll look into it, I’m liking the brand!

[RachFace2921]

Me too @TexasMeow! It seems like a kind of polarizing brand, but I swear by the eye cream.