May Play Box

[MarieY]

Another dud. Are we ever going to see new items? I got the Caudalie moisturizer as part of the birthday gift last year as I’m assuming many others did, I’ve been using Kat Von D’s Tattoo liner for at least a couple years (also, another black liner, really?) and I’m fairly certain the Hourglass primer was available as a point reward which is how I’ve already tried it. I keep debating whether to keep this subscription, but when I get boxes like this I lean toward canceling. I also made sure my beauty profile was filled out to try and increase my chances of getting samples tailored to my skin and hair types, but I haven’t seen anything I felt was good for either. I want to keep giving this a chance because in past boxes I got some really great samples, but this is unfortunately what usually happens. I will say I did like this little bag a lot, it seems to be better quality than some of the others I’ve gotten. And the 50 bonus points is a nice touch if I can remember to use it in store.

[MoniqueDC]

Marie, I didn't think this one was a dud, but I didn't get the same products that you did.    I've been thinking of trying an additional monthly box just for comparison.    I wonder if you have any suggestions?