Sephora

Stores & Services
Find a Sephora

Happening at Sephora

View all

Services

From makeovers to personalized skincare consultations

Free Classes

Get inspired, play with products & learn new skills

cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Post in Makeup Is Life
|

Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

BIC_MakeupMadness_ThreadImage.png

 

Finally, a sport we can all get behind... MAKEUP MADNESS! In the spirit of March, we’ve put together the ultimate battle of the beauty favorites – bracket style! – and it’s YOUR turn to vote! Each week, we’ll have a new showdown, pitting tried-and-true makeup categories against each other until we narrow it down and crown the Community Champion makeup product category… and hopefully get some all-star recs along the way! 😊

 

 

Makeup Madness Final Round.png

 

 

TO VOTE, hit the reply button below and TAG a product you love that represents the category you’re voting for. For example, @AlexBT can’t live without her signature cat eye, so in the battle between Mascara vs. Eyeliner, she might reply with “EYELINER! Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Liner 0.08 oz/ 2.4 mL😼

 

Each new round of voting starts Fridays at 2pm PT, and ends the following Thursday at 2pm PT:

  • ROUND 1 (3/3-3/11): Mascara (👑) vs. Eyeliner 
  • ROUND 2 (3/12-3/18): Lip Gloss vs. Lipstick (👑)
  • ROUND 3 (3/19-3/25): Brow Gel vs. Brow Pencil (👑)
  • ROUND 4 (3/26-4/1): Bronzer vs. Blush (👑)
  • ROUND 5 (4/2-4/8): Mascara (👑) vs. Lipstick 
  • ROUND 6 (4/9-4/15): Brow Pencil (👑) vs. Blush
  • FINAL ROUND (4/16-4/22): Mascara vs. Brow Pencil ◀
  • CHAMPIONS REVEALED (4/23): ????

 

Click the “Reply” button below and vote for your favorite product (Mascara or Brow Pencil!) use the “#” sign to tag a specific one you love, then check back for the results and the next round of voting!

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

Mascara. 100%. It can be worn on it’s own, and no eye look is complete without it. It’s the only uncompromisable step in any makeup routine in my opinion. 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

Alright, almost none of my picks made it to the next round and neither of the finalists are my choices. 😡

 

I choose mascara, it really makes my small eyes pop. Current fave is Lancôme Monsieur Big Mascara Set . I prefer the travel size mascaras with shorter handles. I also love Lancôme Dèfinicils High Definition Lengthening Mascara for a more natural look. 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

@lnum, I've only picked one winner this whole time - mascara. I'm hoping it comes through for me again. 😂

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

@itsfi If mascara doesn’t win I’m boycotting brow pencils until the next makeup madness  challenge. 😂

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

I'm cracking up about how so many of you are disappointed that your favorite categories didn't make it to the final round - because same! 😅 (Lipstick, c'mon ...)

 

For the last matchup, I'm voting mascara. I'd be sad without my go-to brow pencils, but I really need mascara to complete a makeup look. I'll tag an old favorite: Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! Lengthening Mascara Black!

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

It really all comes down to the eyes doesn't it? I'm not surprised, especially given the fact that masks have become such a big part of our lives over the past year. I'm going to go with mascara, there's just magic in a tube of mascara that can't be beat! 💖

 

giphy

 

Sephora Favorites Lashstash to Go Mini Mascara Set is such a great set, and it comes in an adorable tin. 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

@Mcakes, that tin is super cute!!! 🥰 I picked up a few during the sale to give out as gifts! 🎁 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

@itsfi they make wonderful gifts! One size fits all 😄 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

I need no time whatsoever to think about this - mascara! I'm still bummed that lip gloss and brow gel got knocked out, but forced to pick I'm mascara all the way on this one. And I'm going to tag my fave again just for good measure: Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara Black 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

Mascara

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

░▒▓█►─═ Brow pencil ═─◄█▓▒░ there really isn’t another choice here. The correct and only answer is BROWS 😂

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

Wow did anyone see this coming?!?! I still am shocked that lipstick was knocked out so early! I must say Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz and Brow Pencil for the win. 

 

 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

Brow pencil. Easy choice—and not just because mascara inexplicably knocked lipstick out of the tournament. (FOREVER SALTY.) When I say I don't leave home without wearing brow pencil, I mean it. And I keep a spare brow pencil in my bag at all times. 

 

I've already mentioned my favorite daily pencil, Kimiko Super Fine Eyebrow Pencil Automatique. Also my usual backup, Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer Shade 6 . I recently started testing LH Cosmetics Sketch and Sculpt (shade Almost Black), a dual-ended brow tool: brow pencil on one end, liquid brow brush on the other end. I like it so far, despite a couple issues. Won't replace my Kimiko pencil, though! 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

Oh darn it!  I’m still bitter over lipstick is not the champion 😂🤣 okie I vote for brow pencil. I can wear brow pencil without wearing any other make up.

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge FINAL ROUND: Mascara vs. Brow Pencil

@TeamBIC @My vote is for brow pencil Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz . I can still curl my lashes or wear falsies if I don’t have mascara. 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge Week 6: Brow Pencil vs. Blush

This week, in another close victory, BROW PENCIL made it out on top in the showdown between brow pencil and blush! 🎉

 

We're down the the final matchup, BIC. Which makeup category will take home the championship next week: MASCARA or BROW PENCIL? Once you've had time to think about your favorite of the two categories, hit "reply" and leave your vote using the "#" symbol to tag your favorite product within that category! 

Re: Makeup Madness Challenge Week 6: Brow Pencil vs. Blush

574 Replies