Fragrance: Hilary Duff - With love replacement?

[Anonymous]

Hi all,

Ok so after trying Hilary Duff - With love waaay back in the days (2007!), I fell in love with it and haven't been able to find one that feels like "me" in the same way ever since.

Unfortunately, it was discontinued pretty soon after it's launch, so since 2010 I've been buying it off eBay from more or less dodgy sellers to pretty crazy rates.

I think I just hit a new record, spending about 100$ to get a hold of yet another bottle, so I've realized it's probably time to move on.. but to what?? I can't seem to find another perfume that is the perfect mix of warm, spicy, sweet, sultry and goes perfect on my skin.

I've tried (and failed) with the following:

Elizabeth Arden  - Untold

Dolce&Gabbana - The One

Victoria Secret - Noir 

Any suggestions/tips much appreciated!!

-Karoline

[alibul]

I’ve been looking for a dupe for the longest time and I don’t know why it took me so long to discover this but  Replica’s Bubble Bath smells just like what I remember With Love smelling like.

You have to wait for it to dry because if you smell it right after spraying, it’ll smells a little too light and florally (I don’t like florally scents), but then as it dries it develops into a warmer scent. This is my new favorite scent!

[pocketvenus]

@Anonymous You can try to focus your search on oriental perfumes. Maybe try MAC's Velvet Teddy? https://www.sephora.com/ca/en/shop/spicy-warm-fragrances

[30elle]

I had the same problem! I really loved her perfume, I was so sad when I found out it got discontinued. I had the Taylor swift incredible things after, which I thought was along the same line in terms of scent, but that one was discontinued recently too. Glad someone else loved that perfume too!