Mascara Recommendations - lengthening, darkening, waterproof, but natural

[ilenea]

I know, it's a lot to ask, but I'm looking for a mascara that will not be cakey or clumpy, but will lengthen (maybe with fibers in it like Younique), darken, and stay on in the swimming pool.  What do you think?  (I LOVED Youniques old formulation, but their new one doesn't last long in the bottle, and isn't as good.)

[Anonymous]

I absolutely LOVE Clinique’s high impact mascara. You can get it in black and waterproof. It does not clump, and it looks natural. It’s perfect for my every day use, because I’m only in middle school and I don’t like the false lashes look.

[melissabt]

@ilenea,

I recommend the Urban Decay Cannonball Ultra Waterproof Mascara! The brush helps apply the formula smoothly and evenly.

https://www.sephora.com/product/cannonball-ultra-waterproof-mascara-P286303?skuId=1325653&icid2=prod...