Black eyeliner

[Anonymous]

Does anyone know of a black eye pencil that will stay in place all day? My eyes get super watery so everything I've tried has faded within a couple hours.

[arisnice]

I have dry eyes so my eyes water when it gets too windy, or too cold, or I'm laying in bed the wrong way. I use Restasis, but I also wear contacts so I have to be careful of liner contact lenses transfer, where the liner smudges on the contact lense making everything blurry. Stila All-Day smudge waterproof stick was my first find. However, when Marc Jacobs came out with his gel eyeliner, that became my absolute go to because it stayed much better on my lower lash line. Then Pat McGrath came out and her eyeliner is my favorite, because it holds up better on the lower lash line. But sometimes I go back to the Marc Jacobs, because once Pat McGrath's eyeliner goes on, it doesn't budge if you want to smudge it and you're taking your sweet time. It SETS. So: Marc Jacobs, Pat McGrath, and then Stila.

[maria108]

I think the Marc jacobs highliner pencils are very good.

[sunshine202]

If you are looking for budget friendly product. Try the sephora eyeliners.

[naiomyy]

estée lauder double wear eye pencils are great!

[cherylbagwell]

I LOVE smashbox always on gel liner and urban decay 24/7 glide on eye pencil. Those are my daily go tos.

[greeneyedgirl107]

@Anonymous Revlon ColorStay is true to it's name.  I prefer Sephora's Contour 12 Hr Wear Waterproof, though.  They used to have one that was totally budge-proof but it got discontinued.  Good luck!

[themarma]

Marc Jacob's Highliners are aMAZing in every shade, black included. Once on and dried, that liner is ON!

[CorgiMommy]

Have you tried Stila Stay All Day Eyeliner? it works for me.

[veens]

Mine are like that too. KVD tattoo liner has been working for me.

[Anonymous]

I have oily lids and have a hard time finding eyeliners that don’t smudge or disappear.  I’ve had some luck with the following liners –

• Pencil liner:  Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Kohl Kajal Liner in Black
• Liquid liner:  Dolly wink Koji Liquid Eyeliner in Deep Black or Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner in Intense Black
• Other:  Laura Mercier Tightline Cake Eye Liner in Black Ebony

[Anonymous]

The Rimmel one has great staying power, easy to apply and it's so inexpensive!

[CakesCakes]

I have hooded eyes and my eyeliner and eyeshadow would smudge all the time until l I started using the Makeup Forever eyeliners and the Stila stay all day liquid liner.

[IttyxBittyxMe]

MakeupForEver liquid and pencil liners are wonderful! I love them!

[BeautyBerry7]

The Make Up Forever eyeliners stay all day!! They’re waterproof too!

[MelanieIsabella]

i think the kat von d tattoo liner is like 👌🏻

[MelanieIsabella]

nevermind thats a liquid liner

[alexiagreen]

the smashbox waterproof kohl liner in the color RAVEN is what I recommend

[draculasmermaid]

have you tried urban decays 24 hour pencil in perversion?

[Adodani]

I second that! Hands down the baddest-a** liner I've ever used.