Count me in as another user of the Murad Oil-Control Mattifier SPF 15. It's AWESOME!
Although it has the consistency of Elmer's Glue, this moisturizer really works! If you wear makeup, it will also keep your skin looking matte all day, and it inhibits breakouts. Although it is a mattifier, it still provides the right amount of moisture so that your skin is balanced. Just a little bit goes a long way.
I would also encourage you to get a sample from your nearest Sephora. It does cost more than I was willing to spend but it is worth every penny.
I personally love using Murad's Oil-Control Mattifier SPF 15 because it not only helps with controlling oiliness, but it also helps if you get inflammation or your skin gets red easily. I would, however, suggest getting a sample before buying it because in my opinion, it does cost more than what I would spend on a product, and every person's skin is different, so it may not help your skin. I hope this helps and good luck!
I truly enjoy PTR's Clinimatte. SPF 20, Oil and Fragrance Free, and has a matiffying effect!
The Murad Oil Control Moisturizer is wonderful!
Although the texture is something to get used to (a little goes a long way), try working it with your fingers more before applying it directly to your face to have your body heat warm up and make the lotion a bit more emollient.
If you prefer something lighter weight, try Boscia's Oil Free Daily Hydration with SPF 15. It's got a gel fluid texture, is preservative free, and uses silica powder to absorb oil and shine.