Boscia Black Hydration gel or Clinque's Dramatically Different lotion for oily acne prone skin?

[#1]

I have a rather oily, acne prone skin. I am looking for a good staple moisturizer. It has come down to the Boscia Black Hydration gel or Clinque's Dramatically Different lotion. Which would you suggest? I am really interested in the refining nature of the Boscia moisturizer, but Clinque is a tried and true classic. 

[#2]

I have combination/oily skin as well and I will swear by Cliniques Dramatically Different Moisturizing Gel.  Its lighter than the lotion and meant for oily skin.  My face, neck and decolatage feel as smooth as a babys bottom when I use it.  Good luck!

[#3]

I like them both and would recommend taking a sample of each product to try out for a week. I am a huge fan of Boscia and I do love the refining aspect of it as well.

[#4]

I agree, testing samples is your best bet. I've never tried the Clinque, but I regularly use Boscia's Black Hydration Gel. I like the fact that it's natural and delivers a cooling sensation.  It also doesn't leave me feeling greasy like i find most moisturizers do for my oily skin.