Darn it, menthol!

I discovered lip products with menthol make my lips break out in tiny bumps! why can't my skin just stop being such a sissy and suckit up??

i feel like a little girl in time out during recess while all my other friends play all day errday with their fragrance, parfum, menthol, sulfate-laden products. Whyyy, skin, whyyyyyy??? :'(

Re: Darn it, menthol!

Menthol can be really irritating Smiley Sad. I find that a lot of medicated lip treatments ultimately really just irritate my lips; they may feel better initially, but I think they exacerbate dryness. 

Re: Darn it, menthol!

Aww. me too. I cant use a lot of stuff. I tried the nivea lip butters and..my lips had bumps and turned red, and a week and a half later, i have these sores on the corners of my lips. It makes it a pain to eat and even talk. As a self proclaimed lip balm addict, this is killing me.

Re: Darn it, menthol!

My lip area is also super sensitive.  I haven't figured out what ingredient it is for me, but it may very well be menthol.

 

I've been using Yu-Be Lip Therapy for the last year and a half with no issues!  It doesn't contain menthol either Smiley Happy

 

Ingredient list:

Glycine Soja (Soybean) Oil, Cera Alba (Beeswax), Prunus Amygdalus Dulcis (Sweet Almond) Oil, Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea Butter) Fruit, Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil, Camphor, Tocopherol (Vitamin E), Aloe Barbadensis (Aloe Vera), Eupatorium Rebaudianum Bertoni (Stevia) Leaf Extract, Rosmarinus Officinalis (Rosemary Leaf Extract).

Re: Darn it, menthol!

(0) Hearts

i found that rose salve is da bomb too Smiley Happy

Re: Darn it, menthol!

Nuxe Ultra-Nourishing Lip Balm doesn't have menthol in it, neither does Anthony Logistics. 

Re: Darn it, menthol!

Mine get like that too, I used to use C.O. Bigelow's Mentha Lip Shine and Jack Black's original lip balm with the mint scent and now I can't use them as my go-to lip products. I can still use a lip product with mint here and there, but if I'm slathering that stuff on constantly and keeping a methon/mint based product in regular rotation...NOPE!

 

I'm in love with the Tokyo Milk Dark Lip Elixirs and Anthony Logistics' lip balm in Blood Orange!

Re: Darn it, menthol!

For the same tingly feeling, I've noticed that cinnamon gloss has the same effect.

Re: Darn it, menthol!

(0) Hearts

Ooh cinnamon. I'll read up on that. normally though I'd rather not have that tingly feeling. (Too much pain and itchiness tied in with the memories) but ill have an option if I want it!

Re: Darn it, menthol!

@mychoi, i feel your pain!  I have lots of sensitivities and allergies too and it's SO HARD to avoid lip products with menthol or peppermint in them! Smiley Sad  Everybody keeps raving about the Tarte Lipsurgence but they just make my lips dry up and peel.  And one of my favorite lipsticks was reformulated to include peppermint oil.  And Bare Minerals Buxom and Moxie lip formulas usually have menthol in them too.  Siiiiigh.

Re: Darn it, menthol!

(0) Hearts

Oh poop Smiley Sad

Re: Darn it, menthol!

Personally, I don't want astringents in my lip products. View it as a lesson in disguise to be more knowledgable about your products. So many people just put stuff on their face without knowing what is in it. Sometimes, I think people would put tar on their face if it had pretty packaging and were told it was a best seller. 

Re: Darn it, menthol!

Btw that fellow BT 'er I'm talking about in the reply post below is you Smiley Happy 

Re: Darn it, menthol!

Awe thanks sweets! So happy it helped you!!!! 

Re: Darn it, menthol!

That's not fun at all. I love a Blistex Lip Balm that contains Menthol. I didn't know that it could be problematic when I started using it. I didn't have an issue like yours but when I read about the problems some people experience immediately I was pretty surprised. They also said you should use it only for short periods of time, only when you really need it, it's not an everyday product. So I was disappointed but glad that I got a warning before I had any major problems. I really hope this clears up for you. It's Mistletoe season, you need to have those lips ready!!! Hope your better soon. Smiley Happy

Re: Darn it, menthol!

(0) Hearts

I loved Burt's bees (which has menthol) until a couple years ago something went wrong and my lips were covered in tiny bumps. I didn't know what it was at the time because I switched to eos and didn't really use anything with menthol that I knew of after that.  Recently, i shared my sensitive skin woes here and a fellow BTer pointed out that menthol wasn't something I should be putting on my skin type.  it was in both my face wash and lotion so I immediately stopped and started using pure oils to clean and moisturize (plus eos lip balm and rose balm) and my skin calmed down a lot! Yesterday, I used tarte's Amazonian butter lipstick which has peppermint oil in it... And found out the hard way that they were practically the same things. i know, I know... I should have known better. Seems like common sense now that I think back.

 

i didn't choose the high maintenance life...

the high maintenance life chose me. Smiley Sad

Advanced
You must be signed in to add attachments
Conversation Stats
  • 15 replies
  • 269 views
  • 16 hearts
  • 10 in conversation