redwagon44

Help me find a dupe for this!

This is what I get for browsing Temptalia when trying to help someone else find a dupe.... 

 

I've fallen in love with this color, but of course she says she couldn't find a dupe for it, and it was limited edition. 

 

This is Guerlain Rouge G Serie Noire - 45 Orange Euphorique. I love how glossy it is, with the hint of shimmer (which I would be fine with or without the shimmer). But I'm trying to find a glossy orangey lipstick like this! Any suggestions?

 

upload_6330921295200878477.jpg

beauty4ashes

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

(0) Hearts

Looks very similar to MAC Cremesheen *Ravishing* 

melissabt

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

(0) Hearts

Hi Redwagon44,

 

It looks very similar to ESTEE LAUDER Pure Color Long Lasting Lipstick in Melon. It has the sparkle and glossyness to it. 

 

 

<3 Melissa
jenpred

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

I have nothing productive to contribute to this conversation. Just wanted to pop in and say that that is a BEAUTIFUL color!

lmi82

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

[ Edited ]

What about:

  • Chanel Rouge Coco Lipstick in Sari Dore. Available at Nordstrom. Image: Temptalia.

chanel_saridore003.jpgsaridore.jpg

 

  • Chanel Rouge Coco Shine in Sari d'Eau. Available at Nordstrom. Image: Temptalia.

chanel_sarideau005.jpgchanel_sarideau006.jpg

 

The Sari d'Eau (2nd one) may lean a little too orange, but I think the Sari Dore (1st one ) is a pretty good dupe. :smileyhappy:

notcreative

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

[ Edited ]

I think combining a sparkly clear gloss with the top lipstick would get you very close to the original, which is very pretty.

redwagon44

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

Agreed!! That is a gorgeous color, pretty close to what I'm looking for! I'll try that out with a dab of peachy gloss on top

pinktorridora

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

Omgosh! The YSL Rebel Nude in 105! I own it and it does look very similar to what you are looking for.

 

image.jpg

redwagon44

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

(0) Hearts

Beautiful color! added to the 'loves' list to purchase :smileyhappy:

pinktorridora

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

[ Edited ]

I just bought my sister the NARS Velvet Gloss Pencil in Happy Days. The color is very, very similar to this.

 

Also, Benefit's Cha Cha Tint under a gloss might give you a similar effect.

 

**Edit: Check out NARS new glosses in Wonder and Eternal Red. Those both are orange-toned.

mberteig

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

It's funny, I would call this peach, not orange.  It's very pretty!  I would suggest trying the NARS Velvet Gloss Lip Pencil in New Lover.  The color is described as "Strawberry pink", but I find it to be more peachy.

redwagon44

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

[ Edited ]

It's like I want to blend Happy Days, Hopi, and New Lover into one! Temptalia's swatches of those are below. Maybe I could layer Hopi over a pinky color....

 

Spoiler

 

upload_5122319786582046971.jpg

 

upload_4368086961197632948.jpg

 

upload_328413362789953703.jpg

 

 

mafan

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

The color of New Lover might depend on the color of your lips.  I really like the color, but on me it definitely comes up pink and not peachy, and certainly not as bright peachy as this picture looks to me.  (But it's a color worth checking out -- I just realized yesterday how many backups of it I have.)

mberteig

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

(0) Hearts

Interesting!  On me, it is definitely peachy.  In fact, I bought it as a dupe for the Sephora Vinyl Lip Pencil (now discontinued) in the color Gorgeous Peach, which is my favorite!

redwagon44

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

(0) Hearts

I'm going to have to try these out in store to see what works on my skin tone!

lylysa

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

I've read/seen this too in regards to New Lover, for me it pulls up more pink with gold, but I've seen it more peachy/gold too.

 

I think it may be next on my list for lip purchases!

lylysa

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

For a bright orange that's got that blend of peachy-melon to it, try Smashbox's Be Legendary Lipstick in Melondrama. 

 

If you're wanting something more sheer in the color department but still gives a glossy and golden-based shimmer, try Nars' Velvet Gloss Pencil in Happy Days.

redwagon44

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

Thank you! Added both to my list of things to swatch 

lylysa

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

No prob! :smileyvery-happy: Check out swatches online for the products, the Nars pencil defiitely gives a higher gloss effect, and since it's more sheer it can always be layered over a product like the Smashbox lipstick.

mrsbaine

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

Take a look at YSL Lip Gloss in #103 Opium Persan. It is also Orange and has a little sparkle. Might not be an exact dupe, but I think the effect is pretty close. 

redwagon44

Re: Help me find a dupe for this!

(0) Hearts

Thanks, I'll take a look at it next time I'm in the store!! Added to my 'loves' list :smileyhappy:

Advanced
You must be signed in to add attachments
Conversation Stats
  • 20 replies
  • 581 views
  • 21 hearts
  • 11 in conversation
    • mberteig
    • lmi82
    • melissabt
    • pinktorridora
    • lylysa
    • mafan
    • mrsbaine
    • jenpred
    • notcreative
    • beauty4ashes
    • redwagon44
Photos9
  • upload_6330921295200878477.jpg
  • upload_5122319786582046971.jpg
  • upload_4368086961197632948.jpg
  • upload_328413362789953703.jpg
  • image.jpg
  • chanel_saridore003.jpg
  • chanel_sarideau005.jpg
  • saridore.jpg
  • chanel_sarideau006.jpg