Have you tried Buxom? They have nice colors from cream, sheer/sheen and glitter. It have a minty/tingly feeling but it doesn't hurt and is not intense unless you've got sensitive or dry/cracked/hurt lips. It's the least sticky lipgloss I've tried, but I have found it to be a bit sticky on days when I have dry/flaky/cracked lips. When my lips have med/decent moisture and is smoothish, it's not sticky.