Tarte Lip Stain - is "Enchanted" color the same as matte version's "Hope?"

[#1]

I recently purchased     Tarte Natural Lip Stain with LipSurgence Technology  in "Enchanted." I really like it, and I would like to buy the matte version in approximately the same color. Would that be "hope?" I'm a little thrown my the description of the color as "warm rose." Usually, cool colors work for me, but from what I can tell on my screen, it looks to be about the same color as "enchanted." Thanks!

[#2]

Hi, I tried the matte version and I don't think you should buy it, sorry!!! The texture is terrible and it feels very dry and is to be brutally honest a waste of money. Stick with the original version. Maybe try another color like Moody or Lust? I want to try those two colors, I heard good reviews about them, and they are supposed to be darker than Enchanted, perfect fall colors!!!

Don't buy the Matte version!!!

[#3]

I don't think any of the matte lip stains are going to even look close to "Enchanted" in the original finish Tarte lip stain.  The matte lip stains are very drying, too, and not at all like the original formula.  I would suggest sampling the matte lip stain before buying it.

I hope this helps you.