NARS Shanghai Express Lipstick[ Edited ]
I've had my eye on NARS Shanghai Express lipstick for ages, but I haven't seen it in real life (and won't be able to for a while.) My question is whether or not it's entirely matte, because the description says semi-matte and I've seen a slight sheen in photographs that I think is quite gorgeous. However, many reviewers on makeupalley say that it's entirely matte with no sheen whatsoever. I love the velvety look of a matte red lipstick, but I'm quite happy with my Revlon Matte 006 Really Red and I'm doubtful of whether I need to splurge $24 on another matte red when I've got one that makes me happy!
Also, some reviewers said that they've found NARS lipsticks to go bad within a year. Has anyone else found this to be true?
I've got my eye on MAC's Chili, the only orange-based red MAC has to offer, and it's $14. If Shanghai Express is indeed entirely matte, is Chili a better deal?