Try Jack Black's lip balms!
Though they're geared to men, they work great for ladies too and are even a fave among celebs!
I've used their original and love how the thicker formula stays well on lips but doesn't make lips feel heavy or waxy.
There's a new holiday set with 4 full sized balms in different fragrances too!
I'm also a fan of Anthony Logistics' (another men's line, but lady friendly too) lip balm, I love the blood orange scent!
It's a rich citrus scent, not so much zesty, but still energizing.
If you want something with a hint of shine, try Murad's Pomegranate one!
That one is more slick/slippery than the JB and AL balms.