Re: What's your favorite eyeliner?[ Edited ]
For gel, Shu Uemura painting liner, Tarte Amazonian clay, YSL effet faux cils.
For pencil, It Cosmetics no tug waterproof liner, Too Faced perfect eyes liner, Giorgio Armani smooth silk pencil.
For liquid, Dollywink, Physicians Formula lash boosting eyeliner, LORAC front of the line pro.
Re: What's your favorite eyeliner?
I really like UD and Tarte, because they have deep pigment and glide on so nicely- almost like velvet. I feel they also stay in place well. I recently tried Stila's liquid pencil as a sample in black and plan on getting the dark blue color. I liked it for a different look and thinner line. Laura Mercier's baked eye color in Black Karat also makes a great liner when used wet.