Which is better, Tarte SmoulderEy
es waterproof eyeliner or Buxom waterproof Smokey Eye stick?
I really like the Tarte liner, but I was debating trying the Buxom one. I like the smudgable, smokey looks.
Both are fan favorites by many Sephora clients - the Buxom product has 3X the amount of reviews on Sephora.com and both come in a 4 stars out of 5. I have personally worked with both products and can say depending on how quick you are when applying your makeup and/or if you use your finger or the smudger/brush, the Tarte product gives you a bit more "play time" to build and blend. Additionally the Tarte colors are more vibrant in general while the Buxom has a greater range of flattering everyday hues.
Hope this information helps you a bit more in your decision. If you are near a Sephora store, I'd recommend going in and getting an complimentary Smoky eye Express Service using both of these products so you can test which you prefer.
All the best. J