Have I got an eyeliner suggestion for YOU!!! I only recently discovered it myself, but Tarte's Smoldereyes (I personally like the color Fig, a deep plummy/purple...) but it goes sooo smoothly onto the inner rims of the eyes- I never used to line my waterline until I discovered this pencil! You are SURE to love it!!! And it's waterproof as all get out! Make sure you check out the Smoldereyes Pencil, they're kinda chubby and have a sharpener made just for them that comes with! I think they make this in pots too, but I suggest the pencil for inner rims... Have fun!!!