What is a good luxury black mascara?

So I'm a super fair redhead with basically clear eyelashes. I've been loving and raving about YSL's burgundy mascara, but I'm thinking I want to try something in BLACK!

This is a big step for me and I don't want to pick out something bad - because it might turn me off the idea of black mascara forever!

I received samples of Buxom Buxom Lash and Benefit Badgal Lash and I didn't like either - it wasn't the color, it was the mascara. I've also tried and Mac and didn't like it - none of these seemed to be the quality of mascara I'm used to with YSL.

Any ideas?

This is an excerpt of the original post.View the full conversation

I swear by Makeup For Ever's smoky lash mascara. It has a unique brush, not old school bristles, not the rubbery comb like ones either... I wouldnt go for the waterproof one tho, it thickens too quickly


I always run my mascara tube under hot water for about 30 seconds before using it as well, melts the product into a silkier state

Question Stats
  • 9 answers
  • 2 hearts
  • 10 in conversation