What is a good luxury black mascara?

So I'm a super fair redhead with basically clear eyelashes. I've been loving and raving about YSL's burgundy mascara, but I'm thinking I want to try something in BLACK!

This is a big step for me and I don't want to pick out something bad - because it might turn me off the idea of black mascara forever!

I received samples of Buxom Buxom Lash and Benefit Badgal Lash and I didn't like either - it wasn't the color, it was the mascara. I've also tried and Mac and didn't like it - none of these seemed to be the quality of mascara I'm used to with YSL.

Any ideas?

You must be signed in to add attachments
This is an excerpt of the original post.View the full conversation

I swear by Makeup For Ever's smoky lash mascara. It has a unique brush, not old school bristles, not the rubbery comb like ones either... I wouldnt go for the waterproof one tho, it thickens too quickly


I always run my mascara tube under hot water for about 30 seconds before using it as well, melts the product into a silkier state

Question Stats
  • 9 answers
  • 2 hearts
  • 10 in conversation