Retractable eyeliner or self sharpening liner
I need recommendations on great black-brown eyeliner that is retractable. Also like it to be smooth, smudge-able and very pigmented. Pretty please, everyone.
Clinique Quickliner for eyes in very black would be your best bet. It's retractable and you won't have to sharpen it. I've used sephora brand (pencil and liquid), urban decay (pencil), stilla smudge pots, and the clinique is my favorite.