Eyeliner Issues

Hi Ladies!

I'm going to buy a new Black eyeliner from Sephora, and I would like to know everyones opinion on which one I should buy. 

I prefer non-waterproof, and I like it to last all day. My price limit is $20.00. 

I love gel, liquid pencil khol, any kind really. 

Thanks for your help! 


This is an excerpt of the original post.View the full conversation



     The best advice I can give is to steer clear of the MUFE liners.  I'm a huge fan of the brand and they're right around your price point, but I haven't had much luck with neither the aqua cream liner nor the aqua eyes stick liner.  I was looking for something heavily pigmented to make a retro winged liner that would last and resist smudgeing or transferring and these didn't do it for me.  The aqua eyes stick liner stays put better than the cream, but neither was opaque enough for the look I wanted.  Perhaps the brands liquid liner would be better, but you don't want something waterproof anyway.  


Pixiwoo, my two favorite youtube gurus, are big fans of the bobbi brown gel liner, but I couldn't say from personal experience.


Hope that helps eliminate some choices.  Good Luck!   

Question Stats
  • 0 answers
  • 26 hearts
  • 11 in conversation