I've used They're Real by Benefit and was disappointed. Granted, the mascara being replaced was DiorShow. I have to agree with Kiki about Hypnose Doll Lashes. Hypnose STAR lashes had become my favorite mascara! Star and Doll Lashes are very similar. I went from Star to Doll Lashes recently. The length, the volume, the brush, the formula, even the wand is superior to most products I've tried. I have short, thin, blonde eye lashes so I am constantly looking for a product that works miracles! For me, Hypnose Star worked the most magic and was followed closely by Hypnose Doll Lashes.