Accepted Solution
Best Eyeliner for the waterline?

I need an eyeliner that will stay put on the waterline and won't run, smudge or fade. I've tried Urban Decay 24/7 Eyeliner Pencil's and they didn't work. I'm wondering if MAKEUP FOR EVER Eyeliner Pencil or Too Faced Perfect Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner would work for the waterline? I have oily eyelids and watery eyes and not much money to spend on high end makeup so I REALLY need an eyeliner that can stay put on the waterline. I'm hoping my search for the perfect holy grail eyeliner will end.

Best Answer

Stila's kajal eye liner, it's the only thing that I've found last the longest.


I've used UD's 24/7, MUFE's Aqua pencils, and Too Faced's pencil and though they don't fade right off the bat, I've noticed the staying power of Stila's Kajal tops all of them.


I'll use Smashbox's Jet Set too if I don't want to use pencil.

Answers: 3

too faced perfect eye waterproof eyeliner smudges ALOT and super quickly. within 15 minutes it will be under your waterline and ruin your concealer.

I use a Stila water liner and it's worked for me. I also use a primer on my eyelids and under my bottom lashes, and I thing that helps.
(0) Hearts

I use LA Color. Its a dollar at the dollar tree for 2 pencils. For me, it realllly works unless of course i cry or sweat a lot lol. I have applied black eyeshadow seperately on the waterline and that too works great. I have never owned expensive makeup. I personay LOVE e.l.f. it is usually 2 bucks or what i use and its great!

Question Stats
  • 4 answers
  • 5 hearts
  • 10 in conversation