Have you every tried Josie Marans Coconut Watercolor Cheek Gelée? I highly recommend them because, they are extremely hydrating, smooth to apply and it also leaves a subtle stain. All of these shades have no glitter or shimmer.
These shades all look very bright, however when they are applied to the skin it comes out a sheer wash of color.
Chanel Cream blushes are great - they melt into the skin and dry to slightly powdery finish.
Laura Mercier Crème Cheek Color are amazing velvety cream blushes, I'm not sure if Sephora carries them, but they are available at Nordstrom or directly from Laura Mercier.
Bobbi Brown Pot Rouge are good cream blushes, they can be used on lips as well, but they have more glossy finish, I'm not sure if that's what you are looking for.
Hope this helps