ver Waterproof Eyebrow Corrector
I suggest trying out the Benefit Cosmetics Brow Zing in Medium, which is perfect for medium brown to red hair.
Another alternate would be the Lorac Take a Brow in Auburn, which complements warm brown to reddish chestnut hair.
I hope that helps!
Other good options include the LORAC linked by another poster above, and Anastasia products in the color Strawburn. Hope this helps!