Eyeliner for waterline?

Recently, I got a makeover at one of the counters, and LOVED IT! However, within about 15 min, the eyeliner used on my waterline (Urban Decay) had somehow smudged onto my contacts. I must have looked crazy going around the mall with super squinty eyes and asking for directions to a place where they sold contact solution...heehee....

Anyways, I was wondering: What is the best eyeliner for waterlines--one that won't smudge onto contacts? Also, black, nude, or white for the color?


<3 thanks!

Re: Eyeliner for waterline?

I have super sensitive eyes, and also wear contacts and the only (so far!) eyeliner that I have found to work is Estee Lauder Double Wear
Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil. It's the only thing that hasn't smudged or hurt my eyes and has been absolutely wonderful! 

Re: Eyeliner for waterline?

Hi gracey106, 


I myself wear contacts too and have had some not so great luck with specific liners in the waterline. What I frequently use now are the Lancome Le Crayon Kohl or the Le Stylo Waterproof- The kohl is slightly more smudgey so I think the Le Stylo is a better option for you- it doesn't need to be sharpened and has a soft creamy consistency.




Another favorite of mine that stays for HOURS in my waterline without getting on my contacts is the Clinique Brush On Cream Liner which is super dark and sets in place:



Luv&Lipgloss, Diana

Re: Eyeliner for waterline?

(0) Hearts

I have heard good things about the Mally eyeliners. I recently bought a set, but they haven't arrived yet so I will update you after I try them on!

Conversation Stats
  • 3 replies
  • 5 hearts
  • 4 in conversation