I'm in my mid-thirties and super impressed by the Ole Henriksen line. I've mixed and matched based on skin type and concern from their different lines. Recently I gave my Mom who is in her late fifties a gift set from their Anti Aging line (African Red Tea Line) and she fell in love.
The eye cream from that line is the Visual Truth Eye Cream. This can be used AM and PM, but they have an SPF 15 eye cream that I use and she has recently asked for as a bday gift Total Truth Eye Cream. It has a lovely citrus scent and never disturbs my makeup.
Another great value I found is The Art of Age Control Value Set ($55). You get the eye cream, face cream, and anti aging serum. It's a great value.