I have had my Clarisonic since they first came out on the market so it's been a while since I've used anything else, however, I did have a Neutrogena Wave before I bought my Clarisonic. It worked pretty well and I've seen advertisements lately that say that the Wave has a new and improved model that not only vibrates, but rotates as well. It is called the Neutrogena Wave Sonic and I'll paste a picture of what it looks like below in case you want to look for one.
Hope this helps!
Have a great day!